Lefty Trump Supporter's Epic Response to Larry David's Op-Ed Attacking Bill Maher's Dinner...
They Did It Again: Trump Set Another Trap for Dems on Rogue Judges
How a CNN Political Commentator Shut Down the Leftist Meltdown Over the FBI...
A Judge Was Arrested for Trying to Help an Illegal Alien Escape. Let's...
If It Saves One Life?
Joe Biden Attends Pope Francis' Funeral, Reminding Us We're Better Off Without Him...
Did This State Democratic Rep Have the Worst Reaction to Wisconsin Judge's Arrest?
Trump Sure Has Some Thoughts About The New York Times’ Coverage
Jon Ossoff Really Doesn't Look to Be Making Reelection Easy on Himself
Jennings Offers Telling Reminder About How Media Has Botched Story on Arrest of...
Trump: I'm Not 'Trolling' When I Say Canada Should Join the US
Hakeem Jeffries Boasts About Blocking Citizen-Only Voting Rule
Nancy Mace Blasts Clemson’s 15-Gender Lunacy
Trump Meets With Zelensky While in Rome for Pope Francis' Funeral
These Posts From Ed Markey, Amy Klobuchar in Reaction to Judge's Arrest Were...
OPINION

Repeal & Replace GOP Senators Who Oppose Healthcare Reform

The opinions expressed by columnists are their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Townhall.com.

Senate Republicans this week skipped town without voting on the Republican alternative to the Affordable Care Act (ACA) because many GOP senators (Portman, Collins, Murkowski, Heller, etc.) appear to lack the political courage to repeal Obamacare.  

Advertisement

Predictably, the blame game has started: it’s Mitch McConnell’s fault; it’s Trump’s fault; it’s the House’s fault; it’s the fault of those senate “moderates” (Susan Collins, Lisa Murkowski) or “conservatives” (Mike Lee, Ted Cruz).  Or: reform is too complicated; it cuts Medicaid too much; it will leave too many without coverage--as if guaranteeing coverage is the federal government’s job.   

Beyond the personal finger pointing and the substantive excuses, the real reason for the Senate GOP’s failure to deliver is much more pedestrian: some senators want re-election more than repeal. Exhibit A: Nevada senator Dean Heller. According to the Washington Post, Sen. Heller, whose opposition to the overdue Medicaid reforms proved decisive, refused to back the reform bill because he was instead, “doing what’s best for his state and Heller.”   

Bold leadership this is not, but it is instructive. Those members doing what they (falsely) think will best help them get re-elected, keeping 80 percent of the ACA and its bloated Medicaid expansion, are inviting their own demise. 

Advertisement

As the Senate GOP should know by now, nothing’s more offensive to a voter and therefore politically suicidal than failing to deliver.  GOP congressional candidates made all kinds of promises during Obama’s administration (repealing the ACA, reigning in the EPA, stopping Obama’s rewrite of immigration laws) only to fail time and again.   

Frustrated by national Republicans’ failures to deliver, Republican voters in 2016 kicked to the curb all the establishment candidates (the Hellers, Portmans, Murkowskis and Collinses), and went with Mr. Drain-the-Swamp.  He won, and after the House passed the American Healthcare Act (AHA), Republicans are halfway to making good on a long term promise.  And while the AHA isn’t perfect (what legislation is?), it’s a good and necessary first step.  

And taking this first step and delivering on a central campaign pledge would give Senate Republicans a stronger hand in the 2018 midterms, when Republicans defend eight seats and Democrats defend 25, than passing a watered-down bill that keeps much of Obamacare in place. No one campaigned on repealing and replacing 30 percent of Obamacare.  

Advertisement

Not only is passing the AHA (or some version of it) good politics, it’s good policy: it’s unquestionably better for patients, doctors, and the federal balance sheet, and it’s vital to re-calibrating the proper relationship between citizens and the federal government, which was distorted by the ACA’s mandates, taxes, and Medicaid expansion.   

In view of this, only two options are possible: Either senators like Dean Heller never believed in the merits of ACA repeal in the first place, in which case they misled the voters all along; or they do believe in the merits of repeal but simply lack the courage or conviction to finish the job.  Either position is reason enough to repeal and replace senators like Dean Heller in 2018. 

Join the conversation as a VIP Member

Recommended

Trending on Townhall Videos

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement